Session 1-3 | |
Summer Eco-Point Program to Prevent Global Warming: A Way to Save Electricity Ms. Yukiko Hamatani, Environmental Department, Mie Prefecture |
When you propose ‘save the electricity’ or ‘conserve energy’, you
will never meet any opposition. But at the same time, very few people carry
such proposals out. People also find it hard to continue keeping ‘environmental
household accounts.’
Considering this deadlock, three years ago, ‘Summer Eco-Point’ was
introduced in Mie Prefecture. It is a triple-win system: you can contribute
to preventing global warming, reduce your payment for electricity, and
gain funds.
This simple and concrete initiative received a lot of different responses,
including criticisms. Meanwhile voluntary actions have been increased,
and local power has been regenerated, by unique ideas and applications
produced by the participants.
How does it work? In summer (which is the high season for electricity), if your electricity use at home is less than it was the same month of the previous year, you can gain grant according to the reduction ratio. To join this program, participants have to form a group ? communities, colleagues, friends, etc. - and funds will be given to these groups, to be used for environmental purposes and group activities. Since its start in 2001, the system has been continuously improved by responding to the requests and the comments from the local residents. (See table below)
Structure of Summer Eco-Point Program & Achievement in 2003
Period | June-September (joining halfway or just for one month is accepted) |
Target | 6% reduction in electricity consumption from the same month of the previous year |
Reduction % (per month) and Points |
4% : 0.5 points (\50) 6% : 1point (\100) 12%: 2 points (\200) * Those who achieved this in 2002, but under-achieved this year, could get only 1 point. |
Tally for the Results | Automatic tally by filling in the set form (cost for filling provided) All the electricity bills for the months concerned should be also submitted. |
Fund Use | Environmental purposes, and group activities |
Numbers of Participants | 17,831 households (181 groups) |
Numbers Achieving the Target | (more than a month) 5,033 households (158 groups) - 28.2% |
Total Points Gained and Funds Distributed | 15,706 points (including bonus points and those for 0.5) 2,329,875JPY (including the filing charges) |
Fund Use | 55%, for environmental purposes; 39%, for group activities |
Additional Effects
Because of its straightforwardness, and also the economic incentives,
many households took part in the program, which led them to reconsider
their lifestyle as well. For example, people commented, ‘I became interested
in my electricity use after learning how much electricity I had used exactly
one year ago (written on the utility bill),’ or ‘I got into the habit
of checking unnecessary power use, and managed to reduce it even during
winter.’
At the same time, this program has become an effective communication
tool, too. Instead of administrators sending one-way messages, they received
feedback from the participants, and based on what was discussed there,
the contents of the program for the next year were modified. Communication
within communities and families has been also improved, as seen in some
comments (e.g. ‘To save electricity, the whole family came to spend more
time in the living room together,’ and ‘participants exchanged useful
ideas on how to cut electricity, and discussed each other’s activities.’)
Some groups adapted this originally simple system for more unique plans.
For instance, Futami Town where the entire population of 3,031 households
participated, made their own contributions to create extra benefits (for
giving free seedlings or other things). Many groups added finishing touches
to their programs including a point-system by which people can exchange
their points with the eco-products. There were groups who conducted data
analysis and examination. Unexpected effects include encouragement for
people to learn about computers and e-mail.
The Key to Success; and the Problems that Remain
The results of the Summer Eco-Point Program shows us the following key
points that lead to success.
・ Suggestions should not be just ideological slogans, but should be for simple and concrete actions to fit in daily life.
・ There should be some flexibility: the targets and basic framework must be set, but individual families and groups should be allowed to implement the program in their own way.
・ Those who work hard should be rewarded by a fair system (distribution of funds, announcement on ranking to top groups, etc.)
・ Two-way communication should be ensured so that reviews can be used
to advantage for the next year.
・ There should be a key-person in each group to act as a focal point.
The 17,831 families who participated may sound quite a lot, but this
is only 3% of the total. To call for more support for the program and the
residents’ participation, we have to continue working for improvement.
These include consideration about privacy (names and electricity bills),
improvements in aspects which participants think ‘troublesome’, recruitment
for the new participating groups and increase in numbers of participants
(75% of the participation in 2003 is consecutive from 2002), and exploration
in applying the program to other utilities such as gas and water.